Armor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats
Head-to-head spec comparison to help you pick the right floor mat for your needs.
Armor All
$25
Smartliner
$80
Spec-by-Spec Comparison
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Material | Rubber | TPE |
| Fit Type | Universal Trim-to-Fit | Custom Fit |
| Coverage | Full Set (Front + Rear) | Full Set (Front + Rear) |
| Lip Height | 0.5 in | 1.5 in |
| Thickness | 3 mm | 4.5 mm |
| Anti-Slip Backing | Yes | Yes |
| Odor-Free | No | Yes |
| Trim-to-Fit | Yes | No |
| Weight | 5 lbs | 7.5 lbs |
| Warranty | 1 years | 1 years |
| Price | $25 | $80 |
| Rating | 6.8/10 | 7.9/10 |
| Buy on Amazon | Buy on Amazon |
Pros & Cons
Armor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats
Pros
- Recognized brand name at the lowest price point in our roundup
- Universal fit works in cars, trucks, and SUVs
- Raised heel pad reduces wear in the driver's mat
- Basic channel pattern catches light rain and small spills
Cons
- Thin rubber provides minimal protection against heavy spills
- Anti-slip backing is weaker than competitors — mats can shift
- Lip height too low for serious all-weather use
Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats
Pros
- Solid custom-fit TPE at an approachable mid-range price
- Raised lip walls keep liquids contained across the full mat
- Non-toxic, BPA-free material is family-safe
- Available for many 3-row SUVs with rear coverage options
- Clean matte finish resists fingerprints and dirt
Cons
- Fit precision is good but not quite up to WeatherTech standards
- Some users report minor curling at edges in extreme heat
- Customer support can be slow to respond
Our Verdicts
Armor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats
The Armor All mats are fine for light daily use in mild climates, but they're not built for harsh weather or heavy abuse. At $25, they protect against basic dirt and light rain — just don't expect deep-dish performance.
Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats
Smartliner occupies a comfortable middle ground — better fitment than budget brands, at a price well below the premium tier. It's especially strong for SUV and truck owners who need 3-row coverage without breaking the bank.
More Comparisons
Armor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats vs Motor Trend FlexTough Contour Liners Deep Dish Floor MatsMotor Trend FlexTough Contour Liners Deep Dish Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor MatsArmor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats vs Motor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor MatsMotor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor MatsArmor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats vs Motor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor MatsMotor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor MatsArmor All All-Season Rubber Floor Mats vs WeatherTech FloorLiner Custom Fit Floor MatsSmartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats vs WeatherTech FloorLiner Custom Fit Floor Mats