Motor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats vs WeatherTech FloorLiner HP for Ford Super Duty 1st Row
Head-to-head spec comparison to help you pick the right floor mat for your needs.
Motor Trend
$35
WeatherTech
$155.95
Spec-by-Spec Comparison
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Material | Rubber | TPE |
| Fit Type | Universal Trim-to-Fit | Custom Fit |
| Coverage | Full Set (Front + Rear) | 1st Row Only |
| Lip Height | 1.25 in | 2 in |
| Thickness | 5 mm | 5 mm |
| Anti-Slip Backing | Yes | Yes |
| Odor-Free | No | Yes |
| Trim-to-Fit | Yes | No |
| Weight | 6.8 lbs | 9.5 lbs |
| Warranty | 1 years | 99 years |
| Price | $35 | $155.95 |
| Rating | 7.6/10 | 7.9/10 |
| Buy on Amazon | Buy on Amazon |
Pros & Cons
Motor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats
Pros
- Heavy-duty rubber construction resists cracking and curling
- Deep grooves channel water and slush away from shoes
- Anti-slip backing grips carpet without shifting
- Trim lines make universal fitting straightforward
- Very affordable for a 3-piece set
Cons
- Universal fit means gaps around pedals on some vehicles
- Rubber smell lingers for about a week
- Not as thick as the Contour model
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP for Ford Super Duty 1st Row
Pros
- Laser-measured custom fit hugs every contour of your vehicle's floor
- High-density TPE material is virtually indestructible
- Tall sidewalls contain large spills, snow, and mud
- Made in the USA with a lifetime limited warranty
- Channels direct fluids away from shoes and toward reservoirs
Cons
- Premium price — roughly 4-6x the cost of universal mats
- Must select exact vehicle year, make, and model
- Can look utilitarian compared to carpet or luxury options
Our Verdicts
Motor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats
The FlexTough Plus is a solid budget workhorse that handles rain, snow, and daily grime without complaint. It lacks the refinement of custom-fit mats, but at $35 you're getting reliable all-weather protection.
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP for Ford Super Duty 1st Row
WeatherTech is still a benchmark brand, but this ASIN is a narrow Ford Super Duty front-row set. It belongs in a vehicle-specific context, not as the generic WeatherTech winner.
Motor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats
$35
Universal fit — trims to shape for virtually any car, truck, or SUV. No vehicle lookup needed.
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP for Ford Super Duty 1st Row
$155.95
Custom-fit — on Amazon, select your year, make, and model so the correct set for your vehicle ships.